About Assisted LivingAssisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.Complete guide to assisted livingBest of 2025 Assisted Living Winners
About Memory CareMemory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering. Complete guide to memory careBest of 2025 Memory Care Winners
About Independent LivingIndependent living facilities offer convenient, hassle-free living in a social environment for seniors who are active, healthy, and able to live on their own.Complete guide to independent livingBest of 2025 Independent Living Winners
About Senior LivingSenior living is a term used to describe various housing and care options for older adults from maintenance-free, 55+ facilities for active seniors, to secure, fully staffed facilities for seniors with Alzheimer's or dementia. Complete guide to senior livingFind senior living facilities near you
About Nursing HomesNursing homes provide short-and long-term care for seniors who have physical or mental health conditions that require 24-hour nursing and personal care.Complete guide to Nursing Homes
About Senior ApartmentsSenior apartments offer accessible, no-frills living for seniors who are generally active, healthy, and able to live on their own.Complete guide to Senior Apartments
About Care HomesResidential care homes are shared neighborhood homes for seniors who need a live-in caregiver to assist with activities of daily living, like dressing and bathing.Complete guide to care homes
Veteran ResourcesVA benefits for long-term care, such as Aid and Attendance benefits, can help eligible veterans and their surviving spouses pay for senior care.Guide to VA benefits for long-term care
Senior Living Home

10 Best Assisted Living Facilities in Fire Island, NY

Answer a few questions to get personalized results
Who are you searching for?

Assisted living costs in Fire Island average about $5,765 per month. To find the best assisted living options for your needs and budget, browse through 17 communities in Fire Island. Our detailed directory has 301 reviews, photos, and lists of available services, amenities, and activities. Assisted living is ideal for seniors who need help with activities of daily living, such as bathing and eating, and prefer a social setting to pursue their interests. These communities offer a variety of dining options, as well as housekeeping services to eliminate daily stresses.

As you explore assisted living near you, you may also want to consider assisted living options in areas like You may also consider nearby communities such as Huntington, Port Jefferson and Commack.

Fire Island Assisted Living Facilities | 301 Reviews

Showing 14 communities
Last Updated: 12/4/25
Sort by
Filter by
Review Score
Distance
See communities with
Amenities
Providers
Photo of Netherbay at Bay Shore
3535 Photos available
9.2
Review score
8 reviews
9.2
Review score
8 reviews
5 star
75%
4 star
25%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%
See all reviews
I recently moved my mom to the memory care unit at The Nertherbay from an assisted living facility where she had been for five years. I thought the move would be very difficult and I was dreading it. I...
Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
Introducing Netherbay at Bay Shore, now open and serving area seniors needing assistance in assisted living and memory care. Netherbay offers extensive care services to meet the needs of our residents and exceed the expectations of families. In addition to care, the community offers purposeful...
See details
Photo of Atria Bay Shore
1212 Photos available
88 Floor plans available
Pricing promotion expiring soon
9.1
Review score
54 reviews
9.1
Review score
54 reviews
5 star
63%
4 star
26%
3 star
9%
2 star
2%
1 star
0%
See all reviews
I would definitely recommend this to others. My brother was not in favor of moving, but he's so happy there and says so often. We're happy for him and don't worry about him.
Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
Independent Living: Independent living facilities offer convenient, hassle-free living in a social environment for seniors who are active, healthy, and able to live on their own.
At Atria Bay Shore, you'll find a comfortable, secure environment with a variety of events and activities to choose from. Whether it's seeing live entertainment, staying fit with our daily exercise classes, or taking a trip to nearby points of interest, there's something for everyone at Atria Bay...
See details
Photo of Sunrise of Holbrook
1717 Photos available
44 Floor plans available
Pricing promotion expiring soon
9.5
Review score
60 reviews
9.5
Review score
60 reviews
5 star
63%
4 star
25%
3 star
3%
2 star
7%
1 star
2%
See all reviews
My aunt is 93 and lived alone in a house an hour away from me. She didn't want help coming in to the house and she wanted to spend her last days in the home she grew up in.She didn't go out much except for...
Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
In elegant, residential environments, we deliver the finest in senior care, and are recognized internationally for both quality and innovation. Guided by our Principles of Service, Sunrise affords families peace-of-mind by providing today's seniors with a range of personalized assisted living...
See details
Photo of The Arbors at Bohemia
2525 Photos available
66 Floor plans available
9.3
Review score
75 reviews
9.3
Review score
75 reviews
5 star
73%
4 star
19%
3 star
5%
2 star
3%
1 star
0%
See all reviews
Excellent community. Warm and friendly employees. Great events. Beautiful rooms. A very happy place for mom. I highly recommend.
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
The Arbors at Bohemia• Nestled on 5 acres in a residential setting.• Warm, compassionate team members• Single level setting; no elevators or stairs to climb• Comfortable décor helps residents feel right at homeOur mission at The Arbors Assisted Living is to enhance the quality of life by...
See details
Photo of The Bristal at Sayville
1111 Photos available
5 star
71%
4 star
8%
3 star
3%
2 star
8%
1 star
10%
See all reviews
After selling the home she lived in for over 60 years, my mom moved into a beautiful apartment While there she became unhappy and lonely, and after giving up her license and car, felt isolated. We heard...
Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
Independent Living: Independent living facilities offer convenient, hassle-free living in a social environment for seniors who are active, healthy, and able to live on their own.
The Bristal Assisted Living offers incomparable care, the finest luxury amenities, a packed activity calendar and so much more. Call today to schedule your visit.
Photo of Braemar Living at Medford
1515 Photos available
1.0
Review score
8 reviews
1.0
Review score
8 reviews
5 star
25%
4 star
36%
3 star
13%
2 star
13%
1 star
13%
See all reviews
Excellent assisted living program, so Medicaid is accepted. Makes assisted living affordable and an option for all.
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
See details
Photo of Heartland on the Bay, Inc.
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
5 star
0%
4 star
0%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%
See all reviews
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Photo of Sachem Adult Home
Provides: Assisted Living, Residential Care Home
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Care Homes: Residential care homes are shared neighborhood homes for seniors who need a live-in caregiver to assist with activities of daily living, like dressing and bathing.
Photo of Pearl Garden Manor
5 star
25%
4 star
25%
3 star
25%
2 star
0%
1 star
25%
See all reviews
Best management, the owner greeted me and my husband and explained the level of care. after meeting the owner and she took us for the tour or the place we know we were in the right place . The good news...
Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Independent Living: Independent living facilities offer convenient, hassle-free living in a social environment for seniors who are active, healthy, and able to live on their own.
Inline cta image

Our free advisors can help

  • Compare local facilities
  • Determine care type
  • Schedule tours
  • Evaluate pricing
Provides: Memory Care, Nursing Homes
Care types provided by this community
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
Nursing Homes: Nursing homes provide short-and long-term care for seniors who have physical or mental health conditions that require 24-hour nursing and personal care.
We are a 240 bed skilled nursing facility located on Long Island's South Shore. We offer subacute rehab services which offer residents the opportunity to optimize their daily functioning. We also offer long term care.  We have a specialized Young Adult Unit and an Alzheimer's...
Photo of New Brookhaven Town House
5 star
0%
4 star
0%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%
See all reviews
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Photo of Open Gate Assn Inc
Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Residential Care Home
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.
Memory Care: Memory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering.
Care Homes: Residential care homes are shared neighborhood homes for seniors who need a live-in caregiver to assist with activities of daily living, like dressing and bathing.
Photo of Hidden Gem Home for Adults
Provides: Assisted Living
Care types provided by this community
Assisted Living: Assisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.

Cost of assisted living in Fire Island, NY

The average cost of senior living in Fire Island is $5,765 per month. Cheaper nearby regions include West Hampton Dunes, NY with an average of $5,203 per month.

Assisted living costs in Fire Island, NY, vs. nearby cities

Fire Island, NY
$5,765/mo
$5,736/mo

Assisted living costs in Fire Island, NY, vs. state and national averages

Fire Island, NY
$5,765/mo
U.S. national average
$4,698/mo

Assisted living costs in Fire Island, NY, vs. other senior living options

Assisted Living
$5,765/mo
$5,991/mo

Assisted living costs in Fire Island, NY, by floor plan type

Semi-Private
$5,572/mo
Studio
$7,813/mo
1 Bedroom
$8,965/mo
2 Bedroom
$9,270/mo

Senior living costs in Fire Island vs. state and national costs

Cost comparison table showing community type costs by location. This table contains 3 rows of data across 4 columns.
Column communityType: Community type
Column destination: Fire Island, NY
Column state: New York
Column national: U.S.
Community typeFire Island, NYNew YorkU.S.
Assisted Living$5,765/mo$5,837/mo$4,698/mo
Memory Care$5,991/mo$5,927/mo$5,004/mo
Independent Living$5,808/mo$4,692/mo$4,203/mo
Assisted Living
Fire Island, NY:$5,765/mo
New York:$5,837/mo
U.S.:$4,698/mo
Memory Care
Fire Island, NY:$5,991/mo
New York:$5,927/mo
U.S.:$5,004/mo
Independent Living
Fire Island, NY:$5,808/mo
New York:$4,692/mo
U.S.:$4,203/mo
Table showing 5 of 3 items. Click to show less.
Table showing 5 of 3 items. Click to show less.

Assisted living costs in Fire Island, NY, over time

The line graph below shows how monthly assisted living costs have shifted over the past five years in Fire Island and how those changes compare with state and national trends. The figures represent quarterly averages of what seniors actually paid after moving into A Place for Mom partner communities.

Fire Island, NYNY stateNational

Assisted living cost trends in Fire Island, NY

The table below shows how monthly assisted living costs in Fire Island have changed in the last two years and how those changes compare with state and national trends. The figures represent averages of actual costs paid by seniors who moved into A Place for Mom partner communities in 2023 and 2024.

Cost comparison table showing 2023 and 2024 median costs by location. This table contains 3 rows of data across 4 columns.
Column location: Location
Column cost2024: 2024 average cost
Column cost2023: 2023 average cost
Column percentChange: Percent change
Location2024 average cost2023 average costPercent change
Fire Island, NY$6,533/mo$6,252/mo+4.5%
New York$6,714/mo$6,394/mo+5.0%
National$5,375/mo$5,129/mo+4.8%
Fire Island, NY
2024 average cost:$6,533/mo
2023 average cost:$6,252/mo
Percent change:+4.5%
New York
2024 average cost:$6,714/mo
2023 average cost:$6,394/mo
Percent change:+5.0%
National
2024 average cost:$5,375/mo
2023 average cost:$5,129/mo
Percent change:+4.8%
Table showing 5 of 3 items. Click to show less.
Table showing 5 of 3 items. Click to show less.

Ways to pay for Assisted Living in Fire Island, NY

Paying for assisted living may seem daunting, but knowing all your options can be empowering. Read about the many private and public payment options that families use to pay for assisted living in Fire Island.

What families are saying about assisted living in Fire Island

Recent reviews for assisted living in Fire Island

The Bristal at East Northport

4.5
The staff at the East Northport Bristal is always kind. They always have a smile on their faces and are genuinely sweet and loving to my mom. The facility is ALWAYS spotless and beautiful to live in or visit. The only area I see occasional improvement for is the food. It is not always hot and ...
Read more

Maryville Enhanced Assisted Living in Huntington, NY

5.0
Very well managed. It is a simple place with not a lot of frills but with everything you need. Very very clean, well maintained with 3 home-cooked meals each day. Excellent food that can easily be customized. Back yard courtyard is perfect for outdoor time in nice weather. The fees are very ...
Read more

Orchard Estate of Woodbury

3.4
For the overall experience I would have given it a five, except for some minor things, like the air conditioning condensation drips from the ceiling, and creates a slipping hazard for the residents, which I have brought to the attention of the Director and he seemed nonplussed about. He really ...
Read more

Reviews mention these favorite features of communities

Welcoming and friendly staff. Residents and their families consistently praise the kind and caring nature of the staff at various communities, such as Village Walk at Patchogue, Atria Bay Shore, and The Arbors at Bohemia. They are described as attentive, accommodating, and welcoming, creating a warm and homelike atmosphe ...
Read more
Quality and varied dining experiences. Well-prepared meals and a range of dining options are appreciated by residents and their families at communities like Village Walk at Patchogue, The Arbors at Bohemia, and Atria Bay Shore. Special events and accommodations for dietary restrictions add to the dining experience.
Engaging activities for residents. Communities offer diverse activities for residents, including social events, classes, and outings. Families mention the importance of these opportunities for socializing and staying active at Atria Bay Shore, Village Walk at Patchogue, and The Arbors at Bohemia.
Thoughtful communication with families. Regular communication between families and staff is valued, with many families expressing gratitude for the clear, detailed updates they receive at communities such as Village Walk at Patchogue, The Arbors at Bohemia, and Atria Bay Shore.
Impeccably clean and maintained living spaces. Reviews highlight the cleanliness and upkeep of various communities, including Atria Bay Shore, Village Walk at Patchogue, and The Arbors at Bohemia, where residents and their families appreciate the attention to detail and commitment to maintaining a comfortable living environment.
Skilled care and support for residents. Residents and families express appreciation for the competent and compassionate care provided at communities including Village Walk at Patchogue, The Arbors at Bohemia, and Atria Bay Shore. Staff's ability to meet individual care needs ensures peace of mind and safety for all.
AI generated from the text of family reviews

Fire Island review score based on 43 family reviews

7.9
Review score14 facilities43 reviewsWrite a review
This proprietary review score is based on 43 reviews of 14 Fire Island assisted living communities. All reviews were submitted in the past two years by verified community residents and family members.
The Fire Island review score informs your search by letting you see at a glance how assisted living residents and family members rate assisted living in your area. Compare review scores in multiple locations to understand how overall satisfaction rates differ from city to city. Based on recent reviews, the maximum possible score is 10.Methodology: How we calculate our city review scores

Fire Island review score compared against nearby cities

7.9
Fire Island, NY14 facilities
9.2
Ocean Beach, NY11 facilities
7.9
Patchogue, NY30 facilities

Review subcategories for Fire Island assisted living

When assisted living residents and family members submit a review on our site, they rate each community on categories such as cleanliness, activities, meals, and more. The chart below is based on 43 reviews of 14 Fire Island assisted living communities. This chart helps you compare Fire Island resident and family assisted living satisfaction rates against national averages. Use it to assess your needs and develop criteria for your own search. If you know that one of these categories is important to you or your loved one, our senior living advisors can help you find communities to match your needs.
Fire Island, NY averageNational average
Cleanliness
3.8
4.1
Friendliness
3.8
4.2
Care services
3.6
3.8
Staff
3.7
4.0
Meals & dining
3.6
3.7
Activities
3.3
3.7
Value for cost*
3.5
3.7
0.01.02.03.04.05.0
*Learn more about cost details

Fire Island assisted living services and amenities

These charts highlight some of the many care, dining, and entertainment offerings available in Fire Island assisted living communities. They don’t represent all possible services and amenities available at assisted living communities in Fire Island, but support comparisons against nationwide offerings. Our Senior Living Advisors can help you find communities that fit your preferences.

Availability of select care services in Fire Island assisted living

Assisted living communities offer a variety of care services and visiting health care providers to meet seniors’ health needs. The chart below shows the percentage of assisted living partners in Fire Island that offer these care services compared to the percentage of partners that offer them nationally.
Fire Island, NYNational
Full medication management
Full medication management
50%
52.5%
Doctor on call
Doctor on call
50%
33.8%
24-Hour awake staff
24-Hour awake staff
78.6%
96.1%
Diabetic care
Diabetic care
78.6%
97.6%
*Visiting health care professionals
*Visiting health care professionals
57.1%
56.7%
Home care agency on-site
Home care agency on-site
28.6%
30%
Non-ambulatory care
Non-ambulatory care
78.6%
96.7%
Respite or short term stays
Respite or short term stays
42.9%
47.6%
Hospice available on-site
Hospice available on-site
35.7%
52.4%
0.0%20.0%40.0%60.0%80.0%100%
*Including nurse, dentist, OT, PT, speech or podiatrist

Availability of select dementia care services in Fire Island assisted living

Our community partners provide many services to keep residents with dementia or other memory concerns safe and engaged. Below, take a look at what percentage of Fire Island Assisted Living partners offer the selected dementia care services compared to the percentage of partners nationally.
Fire Island, NYNational
Dementia behaviors care
Dementia behaviors care
35.7%
51.3%
Specialized memory care training for staff
Specialized memory care training for staff
28.6%
32.5%
Secured community and/or wander guard
Secured community and/or wander guard
35.7%
41.1%
Memory care only community
Memory care only community
14.3%
13.7%
0.0%20.0%40.0%60.0%80.0%100%

Availability of select dietary accommodations in Fire Island assisted living

Assisted living communities help seniors maintain a balanced diet by accommodating their health needs, allergies, and other restrictions. Below you’ll find the percentage of Fire Island partners making specific dietary accommodations for seniors compared to the percentage of assisted living partners making those accommodations nationally.
Fire Island, NYNational
Nutritionist / dietician
Nutritionist / dietician
35.7%
27.2%
Low / no sodium
Low / no sodium
35.7%
40.9%
No sugar
No sugar
35.7%
37.5%
Vegetarian
Vegetarian
21.4%
36.2%
Pureed meals
Pureed meals
21.4%
17.3%
0.0%20.0%40.0%60.0%80.0%100%

Availability of select dining options in Fire Island assisted living

Our assisted living communities know that seniors want top-quality meals and options for how they dine. The chart below indicates the percentage of Fire Island communities that offer dining options to their discerning residents compared to our partners nationally.
Fire Island, NYNational
Professional chef
Professional chef
35.7%
31.5%
Restaurant style dining
Restaurant style dining
35.7%
42.3%
Room service
Room service
21.4%
36.7%
Anytime dining
Anytime dining
7.1%
18%
0.0%20.0%40.0%60.0%80.0%100%

Availability of select programs and activities in Fire Island assisted living

Senior living communities offer a variety of programming to keep seniors socially, mentally, and physically vibrant. The chart below shows what percentage of partnered assisted living communities in Fire Island offer the selected activities, amenities, and programs compared to the percentage of partners nationwide.
Fire Island, NYNational
Activity director
Activity director
42.9%
46.4%
Pet-focused programs
Pet-focused programs
28.6%
31%
Community service programs
Community service programs
28.6%
30.4%
Devotional activities on-site
Devotional activities on-site
42.9%
49.5%
Parties / BBQs / happy hour
Parties / BBQs / happy hour
42.9%
49.3%
Outings / off-site activities
Outings / off-site activities
57.1%
52.3%
Piano or organ
Piano or organ
28.6%
41.3%
Arts and crafts center
Arts and crafts center
42.9%
35.4%
Educational speakers / life long learning
Educational speakers / life long learning
42.9%
38.1%
Clubs / games / karaoke
Clubs / games / karaoke
42.9%
46.8%
Live performances
Live performances
42.9%
46.9%
Dances
Dances
42.9%
30.5%
Fitness center
Fitness center
28.6%
24.6%
Fitness classes
Fitness classes
42.9%
46%
0.0%20.0%40.0%60.0%80.0%100%

State regulations for assisted living in Fire Island

Safety is a primary concern when seniors and their families look for assisted living. Each state has its own laws and inspection processes to help ensure seniors reside in a safe environment and receive quality care. Learning about New York assisted living regulations will help you understand how assisted living communities in Fire Island protect seniors.
Learn about New York assisted living regulationsDownload the Guide to Senior Living Licensure and Inspection Reports
Photo cta image

More questions?

Ask an A Place for Mom local advisor at no cost.

The information contained on this page is for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute medical, legal or financial advice or create a professional relationship between A Place for Mom and the reader. Always seek the advice of your health care provider, attorney or financial advisor with respect to any particular matter, and do not act or refrain from acting on the basis of anything you have read on this site. Links to third-party websites are only for the convenience of the reader; A Place for Mom does not endorse the contents of the third-party sites.
Back to top